With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made: Which of the above assumptions is/are correct?
- 1. Global warming is causing spring to come early and for longer durations.
- 2. Early spring and longer period of spring is not good for bird populations.
Assumption 1 is invalid: The line, “They found that warmer winters with less snow resulted in a longer lag time between spring events and a more protracted vernal window” is talking about a particular instance. Nowhere has the passage indicated that this is a general trend. Nor has the causes behind it mentioned implicitly or explicitly. The delay may be just because of normal seasonal variations, not necessarily due to global warming. Hence, this assumption is invalid. We could have assumed that this may be happening due to global warming, even without the “global warming” being explicitly mentioned. However, for us to do so, the language of the passage should indicate that this is a continuous or ever-increasing phenomenon. But this is not the case in this passage. 54 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS Compare the following sentence structures: Lines from the passage: “They found that warmer winters with less snow resulted in a longer lag time between spring events and a more protracted vernal window. This change in the spring timetable has ecological, social and economic consequences – for agriculture, fisheries and tourism.” Simple past tense and simple present tenses are being used here, rather than continuous tenses. These tenses are used to denote universal facts, rather than a continuing process. Now have a look at the modified lines from the passage – “They found that warmer winters with less snow are resulting in a longer lag time between spring events and a more protracted vernal window. This change in the spring timetable is having ecological, social and economic consequences – for agriculture, fisheries and tourism.” Here present continuous tenses have been used, which indicates that some process is ongoing on a continuous basis and the situation is continuously degrading. This may indicate towards global warming. We can make that assumption in this case. However, that’s not how the author has constructed his sentences. He is just stating a scientific fact, rather than giving us any clue regarding any underlying/background process like global warming. Assumption 2 is invalid: The line, “As the ice melts earlier, the birds don't return, causing a delay, or lengthening in springtime ecological events” indicates that the premature advent of springtime causes early melting of ice, impacting the migratory behaviour of birds. However, we cannot assume that it’s not good for bird populations. Even when the passage talks about the consequences, it does not include aviaries in its purview, “This change in the spring timetable has ecological, social and economic consequences – for agriculture, fisheries and tourism.” Therefore, this assumption is also invalid. A Caveat: If we confine ourselves to the passage provided to us, option (d) sure looks like the optimum choice. However, we have accessed the source text of this passage, and it is set in the background of climate change studies, which suggests that option (a) may also be the right choice. Source text: “With the first day of spring around the corner, temperatures are beginning to rise, ice is melting, and the world around us is starting to blossom. Scientists sometimes refer to this transition from winter to the growing season as the “vernal window,” and a new study led by the University of New Hampshire shows this window may be opening earlier and possibly for longer. “Historically, the transition into spring is comparatively shorter than other seasons,” said Alexandra Contosta, a research assistant professor at the University of New Hampshire’s Earth Systems Research Center. “You have snow melting and lots of water moving through aquatic systems, nutrients flushing through that water, soils warming up, and buds breaking on trees. Something striking happens after a very cold winter or when there’s been a lot of snow. Things seem to wake up all together, which is why spring seems to happen so quickly and can feel so dramatic.” However, research shows that the Northern Hemisphere snow cover extent has declined significantly in the past 30 years. To see if this may be influencing the so-called vernal window, or the transition from winter into spring, Contosta led a team of scientists that collected data from a network of New Hampshire EPSCoR soil and water sensors installed across the state. They monitored snow levels and the forest canopy for three years. Their information was supplemented with climate and satellite data along with precipitation and stream data collected by more than 100 volunteers across the state. They not only looked at dates when certain events occurred that marked the seasonal transition, such as the melting of snow and the emergence of leaves in trees, but also the time period between these events. Their findings, published early online in the journal Global Change Biology, showed that warmer 55 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS winters with less snow resulted in a longer lag time between spring events and a more protracted vernal window. This type of changing timetable for spring may have potential ecological, social, and economic consequences that Contosta and her team are currently investigating. Agriculture, fisheries, and even outdoor recreation activities can be highly dependent on the timing of springtime climate conditions. A longer spring could mean a longer mud season requiring more road repairs and truck weight restrictions, a possible shift in the duration of the sugar maple season, or earlier lake thaw which might have implications with migratory birds. The ice melts earlier, but the birds may not have returned yet, causing a delay, or lengthening, in springtime ecological events. The researchers plan to test their conclusions with data from a larger geographic area and over longer periods.” (Source: https://www.unh.edu/unhtoday/news/release/2017/03/09/spring-getting-longer-unh-research- points-lengthening-vernal-window) Though, as per us, if we just limit ourselves to the passage provided, option (d) sounds more logical. 56 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS