PPreplord UPSCAn IIT Alumni Initiative

UPSC Prelims CSAT 2023 Question 42: Reading Comprehension

Comprehension › Reading Comprehension • Marking: +2.5 / −0.833

UPSC CSAT 2023 • Q42Comprehension
"Science by itself is not enough, there must be a force and discipline outside the sciences to coordinate them and point to a goal. It is not possible to run a course aright when the goal itself has not been rightly placed. What science needs is philosophy – the analysis of scientific method and the coordination of scientific purposes and results; without this, any science must be superficial. Government suffers, precisely like science, for lack of philosophy. Philosophy bears to science the same relationship which statesmanship bears to politics: movement guided by total knowledge and perspective, as against aimless and individual seeking. Just as the pursuit of knowledge becomes scholasticism when divorced from the actual needs of men and life, so the pursuit of politics becomes a destructive bedlam when divorced from science and philosophy."

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most rational, logical and practical message conveyed by the passage?

Official Answer & Detailed Explanation

Verified Answer: (B) It is not desirable to have Governments managed by empirical statesmen unless well mixed with others who are grounded in learning and reflect wisdom.
We have been asked to choose the most rational, logical and practical message. Hence, each of the options need to be tested for these three mentioned aspects. Option (a) is incorrect: This statement suggests training modern statesmen in scientific methods and philosophical thinking, which is ideal but not practical. The passage stresses that government should not just be an empirical machine, bereft of values. We need ingredients of philosophy and scientific aptitude in government. However, it nowhere states how to achieve this. The need for training of statesmen has not been explicitly or implicitly mentioned. This can also be achieved via guidance, external consultancy, etc. Option (b) is correct: The passage makes an analogy between the relationship of science and philosophy with that of politics and statesmanship. Just like philosophy is the guiding light of science, statesmanship is the guiding light of politics. The passage indirectly calls for the presence of politics 30 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS backed by perspective and knowledge of real needs of society. This line, “... so the pursuit of politics becomes a destructive bedlam when divorced from science and philosophy.” indicates that it is not desirable to have a form of politics which is divorced from scientific thinking and philosophical backing that orients politicians to work for the larger good of society rather than for short-term selfish goals. In other words, it is desirable to have a blend of empirical statesmen and men of farsightedness and wisdom in politics. This is also a practical option as it may not be possible that all politicians have a philosophic orientation and vice-versa. Moreover, the passage has indicated at two places that it is referring to outside help, rather than training scientists and statesmen to be philosophers themselves. This can be seen in the line, “Science by itself is not enough, there must be a force and discipline outside the sciences to coordinate them and point to a goal.”, and “Philosophy bears to science the same relationship which statesmanship bears to politics: movement guided by total knowledge and perspective”. The words “outside” and “guided” indicate more towards external guidance/consistency for statesmen, rather than training them themselves. Note: The term “empirical statesmen” mean statesmen that are facts, observation and data driven, and not value-laden (philosophy can be equated to values). It does not have “colonial empire” connotations here, i.e. we are not talking about British empire or any other empire of any sorts here. Option (c) is incorrect: While the passage mentions the importance of philosophy in science and statesmanship, it doesn't specifically discuss the role of education in cultivating these skills from an early age. Option (d) is incorrect: This reflects the sentiment of the passage to an extent, emphasizing the importance of philosophy in directing and giving purpose to scientific efforts. However, it might be a stretch to say that all scientists need to be philosophers. This statement sounds impractical and extreme. Note: We have accessed the source text of this passage, and it also suggests that option (b) may be the right choice, as the statement in option (b) has directly been quoted from there. Source text: “It is only philosophy which can give even to a life of turmoil and grief the stately peace that comes of understanding. Government suffers, precisely like science, for lack of philosophy. Philosophy bears to science the same relationship which statesmanship bears to politics: movement guided by total knowledge and perspective, as against aimless and individual seeking. Just as the pursuit of knowledge becomes scholasticism when divorced from the actual needs of men and life, so the pursuit of politics becomes a destructive bedlam when divorced from science and philosophy. “It is wrong to trust the natural body to empirics, who commonly have a few receipts whereon they rely, but who know neither the cause of the disease, nor the constitution of patients, nor the danger of accidents, nor the true methods of cure. And so it must needs be dangerous to have the civil body of states managed by empirical statesmen, unless well mixed with others who are grounded in learning. … Though he might be thought partial to his profession who said, ‘States would then be happy, when either kings were philosophers or philosophers kings,’ yet so much is verified by experience, that the best times have happened under wise and: learned princes.” And he reminds. us of the great emperors who ruled Rome after Domitian and before Commodus. Government suffers, precisely like science, for lack of philosophy. Philosophy bears to science the same relationship which statesmanship bears to politics: movement guided by total knowledge and perspective, as against aimless and individual seeking.” 31 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS (Source: https://vinaire.me/2021/08/28/durant-1926-the-advancement-of-learning-francis-bacon/) This further validates our line of thinking.

Option-by-Option Breakdown

Option (A) — Eliminated
Modern statesmen need to be well trained in scientific methods and philosophical thinking to enable them to have a better perspective of their roles, responsibilities and goals.
Option (B) — Correct Answer
It is not desirable to have Governments managed by empirical statesmen unless well mixed with others who are grounded in learning and reflect wisdom.
Option (C) — Eliminated
As the statesmen/bureaucrats are the products of a society, it is desirable to have a system of education in a society that focuses on training its citizens in scientific method and philosophical thinking from a very early age.
Option (D) — Eliminated
It is desirable that all scientists need to be philosophers as well to make their work goal- oriented and thus purposeful and useful to the society.

UPSC Prelims Topic Weightage & Syllabus Context (2011–2026)

Reading Comprehension under Comprehension has appeared 411 times in UPSC CSE Prelims CSAT between 2011–2026. Practicing all PYQs from this topic in timed batches helps build pattern recognition and cuts down negative-marking traps.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the correct answer to UPSC Prelims CSAT 2023 Question 42?
The officially verified correct answer is Option (B): It is not desirable to have Governments managed by empirical statesmen unless well mixed with others who are grounded in learning and reflect wisdom..
Which UPSC Prelims syllabus topic does CSAT 2023 Q42 belong to?
This question is categorized under Comprehension → Reading Comprehension. Across 2011–2026, UPSC has asked 411 PYQs from this topic.
What is the marking scheme and ideal time for this UPSC CSAT question?
UPSC CSAT awards +2.5 marks for a correct answer and deducts 0.833 marks for an incorrect attempt. Aim to solve this question within 90 seconds.

Related UPSC CSAT PYQs on Reading Comprehension