PPreplord UPSCAn IIT Alumni Initiative

UPSC Prelims CSAT 2023 Question 11: Reading Comprehension

Comprehension › Reading Comprehension • Marking: +2.5 / −0.833

UPSC CSAT 2023 • Q11Comprehension
To tackle the problem of pollution in cities, policy makers think that drastic actions like temporary use of odd-even number scheme for vehicles, closing schools, factories, construction activities, and banning the use of certain type of vehicles are a way forward. Even then the air is not clean. Vehicles more than 15 years old comprise one percent of the total; and taking them off the road will not make any difference. Banning certain fuels and car types arbitrarily is not proper. Diesel engines produce more PM 2.5 and less CO than petrol or CNG engines. On the other hand, both diesel and CNG engines produce more 2 NO than petrol engines. No one has measured the amount of NO that CNG engines are emitting. x x Arbitrary bans on vehicles that have passed mandated fitness tests and periodic pollution tests are unfair. What is needed is the scientific and reliable information about the source of pollutants on a continuing basis and the technologies that will work to reduce pollution from them.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical and rational implication conveyed by the passage?

Official Answer & Detailed Explanation

Verified Answer: (B) Knee-jerk reactions cannot but an evidence-based approach will be more effective.
Option (a) is incorrect: The passage suggests that arbitrary curbs on vehicles to reduce pollution are pointless/ ineffective measures, rather than being difficult to implement. For example, the passage mentions “To tackle the problem of pollution in cities, policy makers think that drastic actions like temporary use of odd-even number scheme for vehicles, closing schools, factories, construction activities, and banning the use of certain type of vehicles are a way forward. Even then the air is not clean. “ Therefore, as per the passage, the issue is not of implementation but policy flaws. The passage further explains the flaw, for example, “Vehicles more than 15 years old comprise one percent of the total; and taking them off the road will not make any difference. Banning certain fuels and car types arbitrarily is not proper. Diesel engines produce more PM 2.5 and less CO than petrol or CNG engines. 2 On the other hand, both diesel and CNG engines produce more NO than petrol engines. No one has x measured the amount of NO that CNG engines are emitting. Arbitrary bans on vehicles that have x passed mandated fitness tests and periodic pollution tests are unfair.” Option (b) is correct: The passage suggests how knee-jerk reactions such as “temporary use of odd- even number scheme for vehicles, closing schools, factories, construction activities, and banning the use of certain type of vehicles” are not effective solutions. “Even then the air is not clean.” It makes a case for a proper evidence-based approach as being more effective. “What is needed is the scientific and reliable information about the source of pollutants on a continuing basis and the technologies that will work to reduce pollution from them.” Option (c) is incorrect: The passage makes a case against knee-jerk and temporary reactions. Imposing a heavy penalty on those driving without periodic pollution tests is an example of such a short-term type of measure. The passage advocates well-researched policies, based on scientific and reliable information. Option (d) is incorrect: The passage does not state there is a dearth of laws. Rather, the tone (for example, “policymakers think that drastic actions”) indicates that there are many steps and policies being taken to tackle air pollution, but all of them are ineffective. Further, as per the passage, this ineffectiveness is not due to the absence of a law, but rather due to a lack of well-researched policies, based on scientific and reliable information. 9 www.visionias.in ©Vision IAS

Option-by-Option Breakdown

Option (A) — Eliminated
Arbitrary curbs on vehicles to reduce pollution are difficult to implement.
Option (B) — Correct Answer
Knee-jerk reactions cannot but an evidence-based approach will be more effective.
Option (C) — Eliminated
A heavy penalty should be enforced on those driving without periodic pollution tests.
Option (D) — Eliminated
In the absence of laws to deal with the problem of pollution, the administration tends to make arbitrary decisions.

UPSC Prelims Topic Weightage & Syllabus Context (2011–2026)

Reading Comprehension under Comprehension has appeared 411 times in UPSC CSE Prelims CSAT between 2011–2026. Practicing all PYQs from this topic in timed batches helps build pattern recognition and cuts down negative-marking traps.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the correct answer to UPSC Prelims CSAT 2023 Question 11?
The officially verified correct answer is Option (B): Knee-jerk reactions cannot but an evidence-based approach will be more effective..
Which UPSC Prelims syllabus topic does CSAT 2023 Q11 belong to?
This question is categorized under Comprehension → Reading Comprehension. Across 2011–2026, UPSC has asked 411 PYQs from this topic.
What is the marking scheme and ideal time for this UPSC CSAT question?
UPSC CSAT awards +2.5 marks for a correct answer and deducts 0.833 marks for an incorrect attempt. Aim to solve this question within 90 seconds.

Related UPSC CSAT PYQs on Reading Comprehension