A bat’s wings may look like. sheets of skin. But underneath, a bat has the same five fingers as an orangutan or a human, as well as a wrist connected to the same cluster of wrist bones connected to the same long bones of the arm. What can be more curious than that the hand of a man, formed for grasping, that of a mole for digging, the leg of the horse, the paddle of the porpoise, and the wing of the bat, should all be constructed on the same pattern?
Which one of the following is the most logical, scientific and rational inference that can be made from the above passage?
Correct Answer: (D) Man and the aforementioned animals have a shared evolutionary history.
Correct Answer: (D) Man and the aforementioned animals have a shared evolutionary history.
Detailed Step-by-Step Analysis:
In UPSC CSE Prelims 2019 CSAT (GS Paper-II, Question 7), the officially verified answer is Option (D): "Man and the aforementioned animals have a shared evolutionary history.". This question tests Comprehension (Reading Comprehension).
Passage Evidence & Logical Justification:
The passage directly supports Option (D) through the author's core argument: "A bat’s wings may look like." Option (D) captures this premise accurately without over-generalizing or introducing assumptions outside the text.
Why Other Options Are Eliminated:
• Option (A) — "Different species having similar structure of hands is an example of biodiversity.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem.
• Option (B) — "Limbs being used by different species for different kinds of work is an example of biodiversity.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem.
• Option (C) — "Man and the aforementioned animals having similar structure of limbs is an example of coincidence in evolution.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem.
CSAT Approach & Exam Strategy:
• Section & Topic: CSAT Paper-II › Comprehension › Reading Comprehension.
• How to Solve Faster: Read the question stem first to identify whether UPSC asks for the central theme, logical corollary, critical inference, or valid assumption. Eliminate options that introduce outside facts, extreme qualifiers ('only', 'always', 'never'), or contradict the author's core premise.
• Scoring Benchmark: +2.5 marks for correct, −0.833 negative marking (target ~90 seconds/question; 66.67/200 required to qualify).