PPreplord UPSCAn IIT Alumni Initiative

UPSC Prelims CSAT 2011 Question 21: Reading Comprehension

Comprehension › Reading Comprehension • Marking: +2.5 / −0.833

UPSC CSAT 2011 • Q21Comprehension
A moral act must be our own act; must spring from our own will. If we act mechanically, there is no moral content in our act. Such action would be moral, if we think it proper to act like a machine and do so. For, in doing so, we use our discrimination. We should bear in mind the distinction between acting mechanically and acting intentionally. It may be moral of a king to pardon a culprit. But the messenger carrying out the order of pardon plays only a mechanical part in the king’s moral act. But if the messenger were to carry out king’s order considering it to be his duty, his action would be a moral one. How can a man understand morality who does not use his own intelligence and power of thought, but lets himself be swept along like a log of wood by a current? Sometimes a man defies convention and acts on his own with a view to absolute good.

Which of the following statements is the nearest definition of moral action, according to the writer?

Official Answer & Detailed Explanation

Verified Answer: (B) It is an action based on our sense of discretion.
Correct Answer: (B) It is an action based on our sense of discretion. Detailed Step-by-Step Analysis: In UPSC CSE Prelims 2011 CSAT (GS Paper-II, Question 21), the officially verified answer is Option (B): "It is an action based on our sense of discretion.". This question tests Comprehension (Reading Comprehension). Passage Evidence & Logical Justification: The passage directly supports Option (B) through the author's core argument: "Such action would be moral, if we think it proper to act like a machine and do so. But if the messenger were to carry out king’s order considering it to be his duty, his action would be a moral one." Option (B) captures this premise accurately without over-generalizing or introducing assumptions outside the text. Why Other Options Are Eliminated: • Option (A) — "It is a mechanical action based on official orders from superiors.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem. • Option (C) — "It is a clever action based on the clarity of purpose.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem. • Option (D) — "It is religious action based on understanding.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem. CSAT Approach & Exam Strategy: • Section & Topic: CSAT Paper-II › Comprehension › Reading Comprehension. • How to Solve Faster: Read the question stem first to identify whether UPSC asks for the central theme, logical corollary, critical inference, or valid assumption. Eliminate options that introduce outside facts, extreme qualifiers ('only', 'always', 'never'), or contradict the author's core premise. • Scoring Benchmark: +2.5 marks for correct, −0.833 negative marking (target ~90 seconds/question; 66.67/200 required to qualify).

Option-by-Option Breakdown

Option (A) — Eliminated
It is a mechanical action based on official orders from superiors.
Option (B) — Correct Answer
It is an action based on our sense of discretion.
Option (C) — Eliminated
It is a clever action based on the clarity of purpose.
Option (D) — Eliminated
It is religious action based on understanding.

UPSC Prelims Topic Weightage & Syllabus Context (2011–2026)

Reading Comprehension under Comprehension has appeared 411 times in UPSC CSE Prelims CSAT between 2011–2026. Practicing all PYQs from this topic in timed batches helps build pattern recognition and cuts down negative-marking traps.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the correct answer to UPSC Prelims CSAT 2011 Question 21?
The officially verified correct answer is Option (B): It is an action based on our sense of discretion..
Which UPSC Prelims syllabus topic does CSAT 2011 Q21 belong to?
This question is categorized under Comprehension → Reading Comprehension. Across 2011–2026, UPSC has asked 411 PYQs from this topic.
What is the marking scheme and ideal time for this UPSC CSAT question?
UPSC CSAT awards +2.5 marks for a correct answer and deducts 0.833 marks for an incorrect attempt. Aim to solve this question within 90 seconds.

Related UPSC CSAT PYQs on Reading Comprehension