The interests of working and poor people have historically been neglected in the planning of our cities. Our cities are increasingly intolerant, unsafe and unlivable places for large numbers of citizens and yet we continue to plan via the old ways — the static Development Plan — that draws exclusively from technical expertise, distanced from people’s live experiences and needs, and actively excluding large number of people, places, activities and practices that are an integral part of the city.
Correct Answer: (D) in favour of participation of peoples’ groups in city planning.
Correct Answer: (D) in favour of participation of peoples’ groups in city planning.
Detailed Step-by-Step Analysis:
In UPSC CSE Prelims 2019 CSAT (GS Paper-II, Question 45), the officially verified answer is Option (D): "in favour of participation of peoples’ groups in city planning.". This question tests Comprehension (Reading Comprehension).
Passage Evidence & Logical Justification:
The passage directly supports Option (D) through the author's core argument: "The interests of working and poor people have historically been neglected in the planning of our cities. Our cities are increasingly intolerant, unsafe and unlivable places for large numbers of citizens and yet we continue to plan via the old ways — the static Development Plan — that draws exclusively from technical expertise, distanced from people’s live experiences and needs, and actively excluding large number of people, places, activities and practices that are an integral part of the city." Option (D) captures this premise accurately without over-generalizing or introducing assumptions outside the text.
Why Other Options Are Eliminated:
• Option (A) — "against the monopoly of builders and the interests of elite groups.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem.
• Option (B) — "against the need for global and smart cities.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem.
• Option (C) — "in favour of planning cities mainly for working class and poor people.": Eliminated because it either extends beyond the explicit scope of the passage, uses an unsupported qualifier, or misses the central point asked in the stem.
CSAT Approach & Exam Strategy:
• Section & Topic: CSAT Paper-II › Comprehension › Reading Comprehension.
• How to Solve Faster: Read the question stem first to identify whether UPSC asks for the central theme, logical corollary, critical inference, or valid assumption. Eliminate options that introduce outside facts, extreme qualifiers ('only', 'always', 'never'), or contradict the author's core premise.
• Scoring Benchmark: +2.5 marks for correct, −0.833 negative marking (target ~90 seconds/question; 66.67/200 required to qualify).