Consider the following statements followed by two conclusions: Statements: Some men are great. Some men are wise. Conclusion I: Men are either great or wise. Conclusion II: Some men are neither great nor wise. Which one of the following is correct?
Correct Answer: (D) Neither of the conclusion is valid.
Official UPSC CSE Prelims 2015 CSAT (Paper-II, Series A) Answer Key: (D).
Step-by-Step Solution (IAS SETU — Syllogism & True/False):
Given that, Some men are great. Some men are wise. Conclusion I: Men are either great or wise. Conclusion II: Some men are neither great nor wise. Now, Analyzing conclusion: Conclusion I: Men are either great or wise. False - It can be possible but not certain as some men are great and some men are wise. Conclusion II: Some men are neither great nor wise. False - This cannot be concluded with certainty as the given statements are positive in nature and the given conclusion is negative. Though it may be possible but some men can be wise but not great. Hence option (d) is correct