Consider the following assertion: In the Pleistocene period either the Yamuna once flowed into the Indus, or the Sutlej flowed into the Yamuna and one major tributary of either had shifted from the Ganga to the Indus or vice versa. Which of the following is/are the basis of the above assertion?
- 1. The Nadi-Sukta of the Rigveda
- 2. The explorations of the Sutlej and the Yamuna by Robert Bruce Foote
- 3. The presence of the same species of dolphins in both the Indus and the Ganga river systems Select the answer using the code given below:
Nadi-Sukta lists rivers of the Vedic world — does NOT establish Pleistocene river shifts Nadi-Sukta Hymn forms part of Rigveda (Mandala- 10) — the “River Hymn.” It lists rivers known to the Vedic people from east to west: Ganga, Yamuna, Sarasvati, Shutudri (Sutlej), Parushni (Ravi), Asikni (Chenab), Vitasta (Jhelum) etc. Scholars value the sukta for its empirical geographical markers, which delineate a Vedic horizon spanning the Punjab region and beyond, informing discussions on ancient river courses— particularly the Sarasvati's prehistoric vitality before its aridification—and on the extent of early Vedic geography. Mainstream interpretations date the hymn to the late Bronze Age, around 1500–1200 BCE.The hymn's poetic theology integrates rivers as cosmic conduits of ṛta (cosmic order), invoked for protection during fords and floods, thus embodying the Rigveda's fusion of topography, theology, and practical supplication. The Rigveda was composed approximately 1500 BCE — during the Holocene epoch whereas the Pleistocene epoch ended in around 11,700 years ago thus, there is a gap of at least a million years between Pleistocene river shifts and Vedic texts. It shows rivers as they existed in human memory — not as they flowed in prehistory before the Himalayas fully shaped their courses. Robert Bruce Foote - A British geologist (1834–1912), celebrated as the “Father of Indian Prehistory.” His claim to fame: • Discovered India’s first Paleolithic handaxe at Pallavaram, near Madras (Chennai), on 30 May 1863 • Found stone tools at Attirampakkam, Tamil Nadu • Discovered Belum Caves (Andhra Pradesh) in 1884 • Worked primarily in South India and Gujarat — not in Punjab/UP/Yamuna region He never explored or mapped the Pleistocene drainage dynamics of the Sutlej and Yamuna rivers. His work focused on prehistoric stone tools and archaeology — not on ancient river capture events. Geologists E.H. Pascoe and G.E. Pilgrim studied Siwalik stratigraphy and Pleistocene drainage changes in the Punjab region. Same species of freshwater dolphins in both Indus and Ganga river systems ✓ Valid Biogeographic Evidence Freshwater dolphins in both Indus and Ganga = ancient hydrological connection during Pleistocene What is the evidence? The South Asian river dolphin — historically classified as Platanista gangetica — exists in both the Ganga river system (India, Nepal, Bangladesh) and the Indus river system (Pakistan). Why this proves ancient connectivity: • These dolphins are strictly freshwater species — they cannot survive in marine (salt) water • The Indus and Ganga river mouths are approximately 4,600 km apart across marine waters • It is physically impossible for these dolphins to have crossed the ocean to colonise both systems • The only explanation: the two river systems once shared a common drainage basin — in the Pleistocene, when rivers could move between basins before being separated by tectonic upheaval Molecular studies show the Ganga and Indus dolphins diverged approximately 550,000 years ago — exactly within the Pleistocene period. One ancestral population colonised both rivers when they were connected, then got separated when river capture events divided the drainage systems. The two river systems hence once shared a common drainage basin — in the Pleistocene, when rivers could move between basins before being separated by tectonic upheaval. The South Asian river dolphin — historically classified as Platanista gangetica — exists in both the Ganga river system (India, Nepal, Bangladesh) and the Indus river system (Pakistan). • These dolphins are strictly freshwater species — they cannot survive in marine (salt) water • The Indus and Ganga river mouths are approximately 4,600 km apart across marine waters • It is physically impossible for these dolphins to have crossed the ocean to colonise both systems. Therefore, the dolphin evidence is themost scientifically accepted basis for the assertion about Pleistocene river shifts between the Indus and Ganga basins.